Conservationist Wallace "J." Nichols on the Human-Ocean Connection
Oceanophilia: The Neuroscience of Emotion and the Ocean
"We can use science to explore and understand the profound and ancient emotional connections that lead to deeper relationships with the ocean. I believe that if we do, we have an opportunity for real conservation gains."
—Wallace "J." Nichols, PhD
If there's one thing that unites everyone attending BLUE, it's the common emotional pull of the ocean. Every film at the Blue Ocean Film Festival, in one way or another, explores that deep-seated connection for so many of us, from the filmmaker to the scientist to the man on the street.
Perhaps that is why I was so astonished when I met a man who hated the ocean. Intensely, he said. He described to me fear, negative associations and a general unease he couldn't quite put his finger on. His aversion was so strong—especially when measured against my own great, unabashed love for the ocean—that I'll never forget my bewilderment.
Everyone I have ever known loves the ocean. I'm not talking about lower-case "l" kind of love either; the kind that we apply indiscriminately to pop stars, sports teams and chocolate bars. I mean the capital "L" kind of Love; the love that is unfathomable and ineffable, a fusion of respect, understanding, awe, sensuality and mystery.
A few years ago, I read with great interest reports of interrogators at Guantanamo promising detainees a swim in the tropical ocean as an inducement to cooperation. From those small, hot jail cells, clad in heavy jumpsuits, the ocean must have looked mighty inviting. The technique worked.
A boy from the Republic of Trindad and Tobago helps a sea turtle reach the ocean. Charles Tambiah/SEE Turtles
Later, in the summer of 2003, on a coastal trek from Oregon to Mexico, I walked past a beachfront bungalow for sale in Del Mar, California. Eight-hundred square feet, no lot, but the sound, smell, sight, touch and taste of the Pacific awaited just beyond the bedroom window. The asking price? A cool $6.3 million. They got their asking price, then some.
I've also spent a lot of time with fishermen around the world. I've seen their working love of the ocean up close. Theirs is boundless joy in the freedom of a wide open, big blue space. It is the irresistible draw to a life spent catching seafood. In one Mexican lobstering co-op I work with, the rogue member who dares violate the community rules of "how many" and "how big" is banished to the packing facility with a never-ending view of white walls and stainless steel tables instead of big blue. For them, it is the worst punishment imaginable. Few, if any, subvert the community standards.
And, whenever I travel—which is a lot—I invariably meet total strangers who say: "So, you're a marine biologist? I dreamed of being a marine biologist when I was a kid!" And they'll disappear on the red Zodiac, chasing down whale songs on the ocean in their head.
We humans offer up our dreams, our secrets and our treasures to the sea from whence we came. Those imprisoned terrorists, lifelong fishermen, deep-pocketed property owners and world-weary travelers clearly feel great love for the ocean. But why? What is it about the ocean that speaks to us on such a fundamental, profound human level? I have always wanted to know, but my chosen profession, science—skeptical, detached, dispassionate science—wouldn't allow me to go there.
When I was a graduate student, I tried to weave that big human Love into my dissertation on the relationship between sea turtle ecology and coastal communities. No luck. My advisors steered me to other departments, another career even. "Keep that 'emotional' stuff out of your science, young man," they counseled. Emotion wasn't rational. It wasn't quantifiable. It wasn't science.
But, the human-ocean connection, "oceanophilia" as I dubbed it, held me in its grip even as my career as a scientist blossomed. Eventually, I shaped my general philosophy into an effort I called "Oceanophilia: The Mind and Ocean Initiative." Today, I think—actually, I know—it is time for a new kind of ocean science.
Will Henry/Monterey Bay Aquarium/SEE Turtles
Economists, marketers and politicians recognize that deep-seated, inscrutable emotions, not rationality, are what rule human behavior. Aided by cognitive neuroscientists, these fields have begun to understand how our deepest, most primordial emotions drive virtually every decision we make, from what we buy to the candidates we elect. To my way of thinking, if the lessons of cognitive neuroscience can be used for the crass purposes of influencing what people buy and how they vote, why not use such knowledge for ocean conservation? I believe we can—and should.
We must seize this particular moment in time—when the nascent power of neuroscience is burgeoning and the popular momentum is toward conservation rather than exploitation. We can use science to explore and understand the profound and ancient emotional connections that lead to deeper relationships with the ocean. I believe that if we do, we have an opportunity for real conservation gains that could do some true, lasting good for the ocean and planet Earth.
It's time to drop the old notions of separation between emotion and science. Emotion is science. Let's explore the mind-ocean connection: oceanophilia.
Let's convene the top marine scientists, skilled communicators, dedicated conservationists and leading neurobiologists and cognitive psychologists to ask and answer the most probing and compelling set of questions about the ocean that we can imagine. Let's mentor a new wave of passionate and brilliant graduate students to get their Ph.D.'s in the breakthrough field of neuroconservation. And together, let's mine neuroscience to develop a set of powerful conservation tools that educators, advocates, policymakers and scientists can use to better and more deeply engage, inspire and lead people in the restoration and protection of our beloved ocean.
Who knows what we will find. It's likely, maybe even certain, that the greatest unexplored mysteries of the sea are buried not under a blanket of blue, but deep in the human mind. The lessons are in there. They await only discovery.
Wallace "J." Nichols, Ph.D., is a scientist, activist, community organizer, author and dad. He works to inspire a deeper connection with nature, sometimes simply by walking and talking, other times through writing or images. Science and knowledge can also stoke our fires. But he knows that what really moves people is feeling part of and touching something bigger than ourselves.
J. is a Research Associate at California Academy of Sciences and founder/co-director of Ocean Revolution, an international network of young ocean advocates. He earned his Master's of Environmental Management in Environmental Policy and Economics from Duke University's Nicholas School and his Ph.D. in Wildlife Ecology and Evolutionary Biology from University of Arizona.
He advises a motivated group of international graduate students and serves as an advisor to numerous boards and committees of nonprofit organizations as part of his commitment to building a stronger, more progressive and connected environmental community. Lately he is working on Oceanophilia: The Mind + Ocean Initiative (www.oceanophilia.org). He blogs at wallacejnichols.org.
powered by Crowdcast Gary Griggs and Robert C. Ritchie chat about Neanderthal families getting their... continue
The second Consumer Travel Index question dived into blue mind science asking respondents to share... continue